Ok, this is really starting to upset me. I've been playing Xbox 360 for a couple years now, still using the older Arcade console. had to replace it once due to red rings. Anyway, I've been playing all my games just fine, with the occasional bad scratch causing the game to not be read, but other than that no problem. I recently purchased the new Silent Hill Downpour(used, to save a few bucks). The first copy had a noticable scratch so when i put it in and it kept giving me Open tray after a few seconds every time i tried it, I figured that was the problem, all I had to do was exchange it for a different copy. Got the new copy yesterday, no scratches at all, looks brand new, but when i put it in the console, I got the same problem. Wait a few seconds then "Open Tray". I checked all my other games, and they all work just fine. Does anyone have any idea what might be wrong?