Posted this same thread in the Gears forum, have yet to get a result. Up to about a few months ago, I thought Carmine's ultimate fate was looking to be swaying heavily on the 'survival' end of the spectrum. I could have sworn someone posted a link that had Cliff state begrudgingly that Carmine would live. Yet I've been searching around Google and can't find that confirmation. Does anybody have the proof or have I just been going off of some article I misinterpreted? So if you know where the proof is, could you please link it? Thanks.