I compleated the quest both ways. First saved before talking to sinding then helped him kill the hunters, decieded I wanted his pelt so I killed him too, got the pelt/hide from Hircine. So after leaving the grotto Hircine shows up and had chosen to defy him and he said I turned the hunt inside our ect..ect.. and gave me the Ring of Hircine also. So has anyone killed every hunter then Sending getting both rewards? I have a fully updated Skyrim and Xbox.