I remember being confused early on and I still am. Which was it, exactly, that you needed to make the cursed Greatsword of Artorias? Was it the hilt/broken straight sword? Or was it the full sword? The wiki has my head turned around having it labeled as both and say both, basically. I think the guide mentions using the hilt/broken sword. Anybody got an answer they can give me? Been wanting to make it lately but I don't want to risk losing Sif's soul for the other version.