I disagree with the melee comment! But I don't know how they review games so I don't know if they gave it a moderate score for good games or a high score for a good game. 9.3 in other reviews tend to be like a little high moderate score
SKYRIM deserves all 10s obviously....
GameTrailer's review seems very fair to me. It also confirms some of my concerns about Skyrim... Oh well, I'll still be picking this one up eventually.