I never had the chance to unwrap my Forza 4 game for 360 until this week for my kids as I have been busy playing Forza 5 on my Xbox One and soon will be the 6 this week. With the 360, I noticed that Forza 4's play disc#1 was not being recognized at all as it simply says "open tray". But when we put in Disc 2 on to the drive, 360 recognized it and the screen states insert disc 1 after pressing A to play. The problem is that whenever we had to put in disc 1, we had to press the eject button of the 360, take disc 2 out, and place disc 1 again. Then the dashboard will show open tray again as if nothing was put in while the DVD tray is closed. BTW, the 2 discs are all brand new, straight from the case, and without any scratches.
Any advice will be greatly appreciated.