I bought the new xbox one controller so that I would not have to use the clunky adapter anymore and so that I could take advantage of the new built in "mic monitoring" feature which only seems to work if you have the new controller.
The good news is, the mic monitoring works flawlessly so obviously my microphones are working (I have tried 5 different headsets) and are compatible, however nobody else can actually hear me in party chat either in games or through the app. The chat ring will not light up, however the ring is there which means that the system recognizes a microphone AND since I can hear myself (mic monitoring) it obviously works.
So why the heck can't I actually chat in party? This is the whole reason I bought this "great" new product. Please help.