I don't play split-screen that often, but I purchased Minecraft sometime ago and attempted to play it with a friend. The master controller works perfectly; both thumbsticks do as intended. But the 2nd player's controller's right thumbstick won't respond to any movement (only when it's clicked), whether it be CoD or Minecraft. We've switched out 2nd player's controller with three spares; two wired (with two different controller connectors), one wireless-- none of their right thumbsticks would work either, unfortunately. I highly doubt there's anything wrong with the hardware, considering I can manipulate the Xbox Dashboard's advertisements with the right thumbstick; the problem only start when I play games.
Is there anyone with experience with this that can help me? How did you resolve it?