I bought my XBOX a month ago and have been playing, saving games, ect. I already had a Windows Live account, but my XBOX was not connected to it. In order to play, I created a profile on the unit for myself and one for my wife. Today i connected an ethernet cable so that I could connect to XBOX Live. Since I already had a Windows Live account, I was able to log in on my PC and see that I already had the free version of XBOX Live. So I connected the ethernet cable, went through the setup, and it asked me to create an avatar. But i already had an avatar for my profile! I was not given an option to choose on of the current avatars, so I had to create a new one. I logged into my Live account, and of course it connected this new profile to my current account, creating a gamertag.
But all i wanted was to log into my free Xbox Live account with my current profile and avatar. I deleted this newly created profile from my XBOX but that name is still associated with my XBOX Live account online. Is it not possible to associate my current account with the profile I already had? It is not allowing me to log into Live from the profile I wanted to use.