My first 360 was stolen in 2006. I got a new one in 2009. Tried recovery and it didn't work. Have since made a new Gamertag and account. I would like to get my old stuff back but for some reason noone at Microsoft can help when I call. I tried making a new alternate Gamertag using the original email address that I used when I made my first one way back when. Microsoft can see that the original Gamertag hasn't been used since 2006 and can also see that my new tag and old tag are linked to the same email address. I am just trying to find some way to recover the original and merge it with my new info. The gamerscore was only 900 but still it shows my old games: Call of Duty 2, Gun, and DoA. Any suggestions as to how I can get this back?