I tranferred 3 profiles from my old 360 to my new one. I get asked for the email and password used to sign into Live to create the profile. But, I can't get signed in to access the profile/gamertag. My wife's and a guest profile/gamertag are accessible. I tried to create a new profile using the gamertag, and the system said it was in use, so I know it's "out there" somewhere.
I tried all the suggestions on the Xbox site to no avail.
How can I recover SpiralGenie286, gamertag/profile without using my Xbox Live, Messenger, Hotmail, signon?