Hi JustinMoore, 

It looks like the user profile might be corrupted. Check if you are able to create a new user account from control panel. If the issue still persists, you may try to enable the hidden admin account to see if that helps. 

I would suggest you to enable the built in administrator account on Windows 8

You need to run the command from an elevated command prompt. To do that you need to do the following:

a.    Press the Windows key to get into the Metro interface if you are not already there.

b.    Enter cmd and right-click on the Command Prompt result that should appear.

c.    This opens a list of options at the bottom. Select Run as administrator there.

d.    Accept the UAC prompt

Enter the following command to enable the hidden administrator account: net user administrator /active:yes

If you ever want to disable the account follow the same instructions, but run the following command instead:net user administrator /active:no

Once you have enabled the account, you will see it listed in the user accounts control panel applet. Note that the account has not assigned a password to it, and that you should consider setting one to improve account security.

Also refer:  http://windows.microsoft.com/en-US/windows-8/user-accounts-frequently-asked-questions

After enabling Built-in admin, try to create another new Administrator user account and check with the issue. 

Hope this information helps. Reply with the status so that we could help you further.