ghosts says moderate nat, one says open

I'm thinking there has to be something wrong on Microsoft's end. Mine simply says Strict on the xbox one. Won't even let me turn on party chat. Can't co-op Deadrising. Tried everything from port forwarding to resetting UPnP, DMZ. Even called MS support and the lady said that I knew more than she did. I think it's gotta be them, I've never had a strict NAT with this router.

Same here; OPEN NAT on Xbox One, STRICT NAT on CoD. I've read on other forums (both X1 and PS4 based) people having these same issues. Its more likely and Activision thing.

I would guess that activision is using a port that we do not know needs to be forwarded.

of note when I hit the bumpers and triggers it says I am behind a cone nat. xbox one says this is an open nat,  ghosts says it is moderate.

status code:

0x1040040000000000

this is with upnp reset, etc. I went thru this

support.xbox.com/.../nat-error-solution

portforward.com/cports.htm

above link has a full list of ports for xbox live and individual games

CoD: Ghosts ports are

TCP: 1116-1150, 28910

UDP: 1116-1150, 5165, 27900-27901

Haven't opened ports for individual games yet so I can't confirm that this works but they are the listed ports for CoD:Ghosts, and you need to forward ports to open your NAT

Greetings RANDALL!

Could you verify if your ActionTec MI424WR is operating in bridge mode.

The ActionTec MI424WR is also router/NAT built-in and since you have an additional router, (Asus) your connection will be NAT'd twice. Under certain NAT behaviors, you won't even notice this but with UDP and NAT traversal you will.

Post back and let us know.

My friend is having the same issue.  Open NAT on Xbox One, Moderate in Ghosts.  Tried messing with the router settings, but no change. Motorola router, by the way.  I am not having this problem and I am using a Netgear router.

Same problem here! I have a open nat type on xbox one but strict in ghost. I tried the ports listed above with no luck?

I went into DMZ enabled it and selected xbox one apply rebooted xbox now my ghosts is open after having same problems as u guys

Hey All,
 

Extremely sorry all the troubles you are having. I found this article on Activisions support page and it may shed some light on your specific home network setup.

Reach back and let us know what you find.